02 · CONTENTS
What's in this report.
HOW TO READ THE FLAGS
Green — nothing unusual found at this stage.
Amber — worth a question or professional check before you commit.
Red — a material concern; do not proceed until resolved.
Scalini Group · Example Report · page 02 / 12
03 · EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Overall: pause. Do not pay a deposit yet.
Casale Le Ginestre is a genuinely attractive farmhouse, but our checks surfaced three issues that are exactly the kind that cost foreign buyers money in Italy: part of the building appears unpermitted (abuso edilizio), the title carries a life usufruct (usufrutto) in favour of a third party, and the agent has asked for a deposit paid to a personal bank account. Any one of these can turn a dream purchase into a legal or financial trap. None is visible from the listing.
YOUR BRIEF
You're considering Casale Le Ginestre as a part-time holiday home with summer rental income, with a view to longer stays in retirement. You are buying from the UK and cannot easily visit, so this review reads the property, area and obvious risks against that goal before you book flights or commit money.
The headline issues
Unpermitted works (abuso edilizio). A ground-floor room is not on the registered plan. Until regularised, the sale can be blocked or later annulled, and no bank will lend.
Life usufruct (usufrutto) on title. A relative of the seller holds the legal right to live there for life. You would buy the walls, not the use of them.
Deposit to a personal account. The agent asked for the caparra to a private IBAN. This is how deposit-disappearance scams begin. See page 11.
Our recommendation: do not sign or transfer any money until the abuso is regularised, the usufrutto is released in writing, and the deposit is routed safely. Full detail follows.
Scalini Group · Example Report · page 03 / 12
04 · PROPERTY & LISTING
What's actually being sold.
Listing vs likely reality
"Habitable" is doing a lot of work. Photos show a functional kitchen and one bathroom, but original wiring and no visible heating system. Expect to rewire and add heating.
Photo gaps. No images of the roof underside, the second outbuilding, or any bathroom in detail. Often a sign of the weakest areas.
Stonework looks sound. External walls and lintels appear intact in available photos; no obvious major structural cracking visible.
Orientation & light. South-west aspect over open countryside; genuinely as attractive as the listing suggests.
Scalini Group · Example Report · page 04 / 12
05 · PRICE & MARKET
Is €495,000 reasonable?
Short answer: it is within range for the area and plot, but at the upper end given the renovation still required. Comparable stone properties nearby, by asking price:
Priced as near-restored, sold as mid-renovation. At €2,357/m² it sits close to restored comps but needs six figures of work. There is room to negotiate.
Land adds value. The 1.2 ha plot (if confirmed) supports the price relative to smaller comps.
Indicative negotiating position: an offer around €440k–€455k is defensible on condition, especially once the renovation estimate is in hand.
Scalini Group · Example Report · page 05 / 12
06 · LOCATION REALITY
What living here is actually like.
Year-round village. San Casciano keeps a working population, a primary school, a doctor and two food shops open through winter · not a summer-only shell.
Car-dependent. The house is 4km from the village on an unpaved final stretch. Without a car you are isolated; in winter the track may need maintenance.
Tourism seasonality. Strong July–September rental demand; quiet November–March. Good for a summer let, weaker for year-round income.
Noise & neighbours. No road, rail or industrial noise nearby. Nearest neighbour ~300m. Genuinely quiet.
Safety & local risk. Low-crime rural comune per public records; main practical risks are isolation and the unpaved access in winter, not security. Healthcare and a primary school operate locally (see page 7).
NEARBY AREAS WORTH COMPARING
SUITABILITY BY USE
Scalini Group · Example Report · page 06 / 12
07 · PRACTICAL ACCESS
Getting there, and getting online.
Connectivity
Internet to confirm. Fibre reaches the village but likely not the final 4km. Expect FWA or fixed-wireless; verify a real line speed before relying on remote work.
Mobile coverage. Good 4G on the main networks at the property per coverage maps.
Utilities. Mains electricity present; confirm water source (mains vs well) and absence of mains gas (likely LPG).
Scalini Group · Example Report · page 07 / 12
08 · RENOVATION & MAINTENANCE
The work the price hides.
Indicative ranges only, pending a geometra survey. These are planning figures to test the deal, not quotes.
The listing's implied "€60k to finish" is not realistic for the work visible. Treat the all-in cost as roughly €600k–€680k including purchase, taxes and renovation.
Scalini Group · Example Report · page 08 / 12
09 · DOCUMENTS
Title, charges & what's missing.
Why this page matters most. A usufrutto or uncleared ipoteca follows the property to you, the buyer. In Italy, debts and occupancy rights attach to the house, not the seller. None of these were disclosed in the listing; all were found by checking the title.
Scalini Group · Example Report · page 09 / 12
10 · CATASTO & PLANNING
Questions for a geometra.
These are not conclusions. They are the specific points a licensed geometra should verify. We have framed them so you can hand this page straight over.
Does the registered planimetria match the building as it stands today? We noted an extra ground-floor room not obviously on the plan.
Are all past works permitted, or is a sanatoria (amnesty) outstanding on any part of the structure?
What is the cadastral category, and can it be changed to support a primary residence / the renovation you intend?
Do the registered boundaries match the fenced garden and the second outbuilding? Confirm the parcel numbers included in the sale.
Are there easements or rights of way over the access track, and who is responsible for its maintenance?
Are there landscape or heritage constraints (vincolo paesaggistico) affecting what you can change externally?
Scalini Group · Example Report · page 10 / 12
11 · SELLER, AGENT & PROCESS
The deposit is where money disappears.
RED FLAG · DEPOSIT REQUEST
The agent asked for a €15,000 caparra wired to a personal bank account to "hold the property." This is the single most common way foreign buyers lose money in Italy. A genuine deposit is named in a written proposta and held by the notary, the agency's escrow, or via traceable bank draft · never a private account, never in cash, never to rush you.
Agency is registered. The listing agent has a verifiable REA number · good. But a real agency can still mishandle a deposit, so the route matters more than the badge.
Sale via inheritance. Public signals suggest the property is sold by heirs. Confirm all heirs consent and the succession is registered · a common source of delay.
Commission both sides. Budget agency commission (typically ~3% + VAT) on the buyer side, standard in Italy.
ASK THE AGENT BEFORE PROCEEDING
1. Why is the deposit going to a personal account, and not the notary or escrow?
2. Is the succession registered and do all heirs agree to sell?
3. Will the seller release the usufrutto in writing before completion?
4. Are there any mortgages, liens or rights of way registered on the property?
5. Will you regularise the unpermitted room, or reflect it in the price?
Scalini Group · Example Report · page 11 / 12
12 · RECOMMENDATION
Where we'd leave it.
VERDICT · PAUSE, RESOLVE BEFORE COMMITTING
A beautiful property worth keeping alive, but not at today's terms. The unpermitted works, the usufruct and the deposit request must each be cleared in writing before any money moves. Handled properly, these are fixable; ignored, any one could cost you the house or the deposit.
Suggested next steps
Do not transfer any deposit until it is routed through the notary or a registered escrow · never a personal account.
Have a notary confirm the title is free of the usufrutto, mortgages and pre-emption rights before you offer.
Require the seller to regularise the abuso edilizio (or price it in) before completion.
Make any proposta conditional on all of the above, with your deposit fully refundable if they are not met.
Scalini Group
This is an illustrative example for a fictional property. Scalini Group provides independent buyer-side advisory and research. We are not a law firm, notary or estate agency, and this report is not legal, tax, structural or valuation advice. Formal checks must be carried out by licensed professionals. Figures are indicative planning estimates only.
Scalini Group · Example Report · page 12 / 12